한국어

움직이는평화교실

글 수 21

가르침을 학생들에게 의존하기

 

 

 

    호스트인 여교수는 나를 주차장으로 안내하면서 이렇게 말했다. “정말 멋졌어요! 학생들이 그처럼 생기 넘치게 반응하는 것은 처음 보았어요. 당신은 학생들이 대화를 촉진하기 위해 두 가지 정도 탁월한 테크닉을 구사하더군요.” 그녀는 나를 잘 모르고 있는 게 분명했다. 그 상황에서 테크닉이란 말을 쓴 걸 보면!

    하지만 나는 궁금했다.

    “무슨 말씀이죠?”

    “학생들의 손이 올라갈 때마다, 당신은 상체를 그 학생 쪽으로 숙이며 이런 동작을 했어요.” 그 여교수는 손으로 학생을 부르는동작을 해 보였다. “그리고는 어서...’하고 말했어요. 그런 다음에 학생이 무슨 말을 하든, 당신은 미소를 지으면서 대답했어요. ‘고맙습니다.’ 당신은 진정으로 고마워하는 사람 같아 보였어요.”

    그 여교수는 그런 동작이 학생들이 감정을 조종하기 위한 전략적인 행동이라고 생각하는 것 같았다. 하지만 그건 사실이 아니었다. 그것은 죽어가는 사람의 필사적인 행동이었다!

    내가 어서......”하고 말하면서 애원의 손짓을 한 것은 정말 애원하고 싶은 심정이었기 때문이다. 내가 작은 반응에도 감사합니다라고 말한 것은 정말 감사를 느꼈기 때문이다. 나는 그날 무려 한 시간을 남겨둔 상태에서 강연을 끝냈다. 만약 학생들이 질문을 하지 않는다면 공개적인 웃음거리가 될 판이었다. 우리의 만남이 가치 있는 어떤 것이 되려면 학생들이 협조가 절대적으로 필요했다. 그래서 자연스럽게 애원과 감사의 동작이 나오게 된 것이다.

    우리가 자기 보호적인 전문가의 자율성을 벗어 던지고 학생들이 우리에게 의존하는 것처럼 우리도 학생들에게 의존한다면, 진리의 커뮤니티가 요구하는 상호의존성에 좀더 가깝게 다가갈 수 있다. 학생들이 필요해서 어서.....”하고 자발적으로 말하고 학생들이 고마워서 감사합니다라고 말할 때, 커뮤니티를 가로막는 장애물은 저절로 사라질 것이다. 그리하여 교사와 학생은 의미와 상호연결성의 새로운 깊이에서 만나게 될 것이고, 모든 학생은 놀라우면서도 생기발랄한 방식으로 학습 효과를 거두게 될 것이다.

 

 

- 파커 파머, <가르칠 수 있는 용기>중에서

엮인글 :

댓글 '2'

chenyingying

2017.09.21 10:53:39
*.167.23.170

new

d&g sunglasses

nike trainers uk

jordan shoes

nike blazer

ugg boots

the north face outlet

salvatore ferragamo

columbia outlet

vans outlet

under armour clearance

louis vuitton handbags

louis vuitton outlet

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses cheap

kate spade outlet store

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg boots outlet

coach outlet

ugg outlet

nike factory store

ugg boots

ugg outlet store

ugg boots clearance

thibaut courtois jersey

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

louis vuitton outlet

prada outlet

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

montblanc pen

michael kors outlet clearance

air jordans

the north face

michael kors

nike outlet 30% off

uggs outlet

louis vuitton

mlb jerseys

ugg outlet online

armani sunglasses

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas stan smith shoes

moncler jacket outlet

prada outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ray ban sunglasses

soccer jerseys

mbt outlet

louis vuitton outlet

christian louboutin outlet

adidas yeezy

uggs outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

canada goose for sale

north face outlet

kate spade outlet online

ugg boots

oakley vault

christian louboutin sale

ralph lauren polo

nike outlet store

giuseppe zanotti sneakers

adidas stan smith

true religion jeans

cheap ray ban sunglasses

uggs australia

ugg outlet

christian louboutin outlet

oakley vault

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

vibram five fingers

fitflops sandals

ralph lauren polo

uggs clearance

polo ralph lauren outlet

moncler uk

ugg boots

coach outlet

supreme shirts

nike factory store

tommy hilfiger canada

cheap jerseys

nhl jerseys wholesale

mk väska

yeezy 350 v2

air max uk

louis vuitton outlet

adidas outlet store

ugg outlet

fitflops shoes

pandora charms

ugg sale

supreme clothing

chaussure yeezy

ugg outlet

louis vuitton handbags

michael kors handbags

pandora jewelry

polo ralph lauren outlet

tory burch

birkenstock uk

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors canada

cheap nhl jerseys

mk väska

cartier glasses

supreme outlet

michael kors handtaschen

christian louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses outlet

ugg australia

michael kors outlet

michael kors uk

red bottom heels

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

nike huarache

salvatore ferragamo outlet

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren uk

uggs outlet online

ugg boots

north face clearance

canada goose canada

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

adidas outlet

nike air max

cheap jordans

mcm handbags

canada goose outlet

superdry uk

sac longchamp

fitflops sale

manolo blahnik outlet

coach factory outlet

burberry handbags

coach bags

chicago blackhawks jersey

adidas yeezy boost 350

christian louboutin outlet

pandora bracelet

michael kors handbags

the north face outlet

fitflops clearance

christian louboutin shoes

adidas nmd runner

ugg boots

ugg boots

ugg boots clearance

mulberry uk

the north face outlet

fitflops shoes

tory burch outlet

adidas outlet clearance

coach factory online

longchamp outlet store

tory burch outlet

coach factory outlet

ugg boots

gafas de sol ray ban 2017

air jordan retro

ralph lauren outlet

nike nfl jerseys

true religion jeans

polo outlet

uggs outlet

prada outlet

oakley sunglasses cheap

coach handbags

cheap nfl jerseys

fitflops shoes

cheap mlb jerseys

north face jackets

polo ralph lauren outlet

uggs slippers

polo ralph lauren shirts

under armour shoes

coach outlet

nike nfl jerseys

ugg boots

moncler outlet

ray ban zonnebril sale

ray ban sunglasses

hermes birkin handbags

ugg boots uk

ugg outlet

canada goose sale

coach outlet online

ugg boots

christian louboutin uk

ugg factory outlet

nike air force 1

uggs outlet

mulberry bags

cheap ugg boots

nike air max online

cheap uggs outlet

yeezy boost 350 v2

nfl jerseys from china

ugg clearance

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion uk

adidas jeremy scott

superdry clothing

north face outlet

mulberry sale

ugg australia

coach outlet 70% off

ray ban sunglasses

burberry sale

cheap nfl jerseys

the north face outlet

ray ban sunglasses

uggs outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

mac cosmetics makeup

authentic nfl jerseys

ralph lauren italia

coach outlet online

ugg boots

ugg factory outlet

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet online

burberry outlet

ugg australia

michael kors handbags

true religion jeans

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

ralph lauren shirts

cheap jordans

ugg boots clearance

rolex watches

christian louboutin shoes

uggs classic boots

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet online

uggs outlet

polo ralph lauren

adidas wings

burberry scarves

carrera sunglasses

supra shoes

prada handbags

ugg boots on sale 65% off

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg boots

ugg outlet online

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

nike running

coach outlet online

ugg sale

michael kors outlet 75% off

prada glasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

hermes handbags

longchamp bags

michael kors handtaschen

calvin klein underwear

ray ban online

polo ralph lauren outlet

true religion outlet

michael kors damenuhr

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

dior sunglasses

north face outlet

fitflops sale

ugg boots

ralph lauren uk

true religion outlet

cheap ugg boots

cheap michael kors handbags

louis vuitton outlet

montre rolex homme

coach outlet

north face jackets

mont blanc ballpoint pens

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ray ban uk

michael kors canada

canada goose canada

hermes belt outlet

adidas soccer cleats

rolex oyster perpetual

rolex online store

pandora charms

canada goose clearance

michael kors handtaschen

kate spade sale

north face outlet

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren sale

hermes birkin bag

coach outlet

cheap jordan shoes

mlb jerseys

coach wallets

yeezy 350 v2

polo ralph lauren pas cher

ugg boots outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

red bottoms

michael kors outlet

jordan shoes

ray ban sunglasses

coach factory outlet

uggs outlet

nike huarache shoes

kate spade sale

louis vuitton outlet

cheap snapbacks

nike factory outlet

louboutin outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren t shirt

moncler jacket

cheap oakley sunglasses

versace glasses

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors bags

coach outlet

air jordan shoes

adidas trainers uk

moncler jacket

michael kors outlet

ferragamo shoes

kate spade outlet

cheap nba jerseys

discount nike

canada goose outlet

coach outlet online 70% off

ugg boots

cheap ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

converse shoes

ugg canada

cheap jordans

nike air max 95

michael kors outlet online

uggs outlet online

new balance shoes

cheap jordan shoes

ugg australia

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots

rolex datejust 2

birkenstock sandals

retro jordans

nfl jerseys

coach outlet online

christian louboutin outlet

nike roshe run

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren outlet

paul pogba jersey

ugg slippers

ugg australia boots

polo ralph lauren outlet

cheap jordan shoes

longchamp handbags

longchamp outlet

kate spade outlet

nike shoes

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

adidas trainers

adidas shoes

ugg boots outlet

mk taschen

polo ralph lauren

ugg sale

salvatore ferragamo belt

michael kors uk

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

tory burch outlet online

uggs canada

uggs clearance

prada outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren españa

oakley sunglasses

rolex daytona

ralph lauren

ugg boots outlet

burberry canada

swarovski crystal

adidas originals

tory burch outlet online

hermes birkin bag

christian louboutin pas cher

ugg sale

montblanc pens

fitflops sale clearance

pandora canada

true religion sale

replica watches

cheap jordan shoes

north face outlet

burberry sale

moncler outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban aviators

cheap nfl jerseys

ugg boots on sale

ugg slippers

baseball jerseys

louis vuitton handbags

cheap oakley sunglasses

fitflop outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

ugg boots on sale

occhiali da sole ray ban

pandora charms

yeezy boost 350

ray ban sunglasses

burberry outlet online

coach outlet

uggs uk

ralph lauren outlet

nike store

birkenstock outlet

chenyingying20170921

chenyingying

2017.09.21 11:15:21
*.167.23.170

new

d&g sunglasses

nike trainers uk

jordan shoes

nike blazer

ugg boots

the north face outlet

salvatore ferragamo

columbia outlet

vans outlet

under armour clearance

louis vuitton handbags

louis vuitton outlet

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses cheap

kate spade outlet store

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg boots outlet

coach outlet

ugg outlet

nike factory store

ugg boots

ugg outlet store

ugg boots clearance

thibaut courtois jersey

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

louis vuitton outlet

prada outlet

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

montblanc pen

michael kors outlet clearance

air jordans

the north face

michael kors

nike outlet 30% off

uggs outlet

louis vuitton

mlb jerseys

ugg outlet online

armani sunglasses

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

adidas stan smith shoes

moncler jacket outlet

prada outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ray ban sunglasses

soccer jerseys

mbt outlet

louis vuitton outlet

christian louboutin outlet

adidas yeezy

uggs outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

canada goose for sale

north face outlet

kate spade outlet online

ugg boots

oakley vault

christian louboutin sale

ralph lauren polo

nike outlet store

giuseppe zanotti sneakers

adidas stan smith

true religion jeans

cheap ray ban sunglasses

uggs australia

ugg outlet

christian louboutin outlet

oakley vault

ugg outlet

coach factory outlet

vibram five fingers

fitflops sandals

ralph lauren polo

uggs clearance

polo ralph lauren outlet

moncler uk

ugg boots

coach outlet

supreme shirts

nike factory store

tommy hilfiger canada

cheap jerseys

nhl jerseys wholesale

mk väska

yeezy 350 v2

air max uk

louis vuitton outlet

adidas outlet store

ugg outlet

fitflops shoes

pandora charms

ugg sale

supreme clothing

chaussure yeezy

ugg outlet

louis vuitton handbags

michael kors handbags

pandora jewelry

polo ralph lauren outlet

tory burch

birkenstock uk

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors canada

cheap nhl jerseys

mk väska

cartier glasses

supreme outlet

michael kors handtaschen

christian louboutin shoes

oakley sunglasses outlet

ugg australia

michael kors outlet

michael kors uk

red bottom heels

coach factory outlet

yeezy boost 350

nike huarache

salvatore ferragamo outlet

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren uk

uggs outlet online

ugg boots

north face clearance

canada goose canada

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

adidas outlet

nike air max

cheap jordans

mcm handbags

canada goose outlet

superdry uk

sac longchamp

fitflops sale

manolo blahnik outlet

coach factory outlet

burberry handbags

coach bags

chicago blackhawks jersey

adidas yeezy boost 350

christian louboutin outlet

pandora bracelet

michael kors handbags

the north face outlet

fitflops clearance

christian louboutin shoes

adidas nmd runner

ugg boots

ugg boots

ugg boots clearance

mulberry uk

the north face outlet

fitflops shoes

tory burch outlet

adidas outlet clearance

coach factory online

longchamp outlet store

tory burch outlet

coach factory outlet

ugg boots

gafas de sol ray ban 2017

air jordan retro

ralph lauren outlet

nike nfl jerseys

true religion jeans

polo outlet

uggs outlet

prada outlet

oakley sunglasses cheap

coach handbags

cheap nfl jerseys

fitflops shoes

cheap mlb jerseys

north face jackets

polo ralph lauren outlet

uggs slippers

polo ralph lauren shirts

under armour shoes

coach outlet

nike nfl jerseys

ugg boots

moncler outlet

ray ban zonnebril sale

ray ban sunglasses

hermes birkin handbags

ugg boots uk

ugg outlet

canada goose sale

coach outlet online

ugg boots

christian louboutin uk

ugg factory outlet

nike air force 1

uggs outlet

mulberry bags

cheap ugg boots

nike air max online

cheap uggs outlet

yeezy boost 350 v2

nfl jerseys from china

ugg clearance

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses wholesale

true religion uk

adidas jeremy scott

superdry clothing

north face outlet

mulberry sale

ugg australia

coach outlet 70% off

ray ban sunglasses

burberry sale

cheap nfl jerseys

the north face outlet

ray ban sunglasses

uggs outlet

pandora jewelry outlet

mac cosmetics makeup

authentic nfl jerseys

ralph lauren italia

coach outlet online

ugg boots

ugg factory outlet

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet online

burberry outlet

ugg australia

michael kors handbags

true religion jeans

pandora jewelry

michael kors handbags

ralph lauren shirts

cheap jordans

ugg boots clearance

rolex watches

christian louboutin shoes

uggs classic boots

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet online

uggs outlet

polo ralph lauren

adidas wings

burberry scarves

carrera sunglasses

supra shoes

prada handbags

ugg boots on sale 65% off

coach outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg boots

ugg outlet online

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

nike running

coach outlet online

ugg sale

michael kors outlet 75% off

prada glasses

cheap oakley sunglasses

hermes handbags

longchamp bags

michael kors handtaschen

calvin klein underwear

ray ban online

polo ralph lauren outlet

true religion outlet

michael kors damenuhr

coach outlet

coach outlet store online

dior sunglasses

north face outlet

fitflops sale

ugg boots

ralph lauren uk

true religion outlet

cheap ugg boots

cheap michael kors handbags

louis vuitton outlet

montre rolex homme

coach outlet

north face jackets

mont blanc ballpoint pens

ray ban sunglasses outlet

ray ban uk

michael kors canada

canada goose canada

hermes belt outlet

adidas soccer cleats

rolex oyster perpetual

rolex online store

pandora charms

canada goose clearance

michael kors handtaschen

kate spade sale

north face outlet

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren sale

hermes birkin bag

coach outlet

cheap jordan shoes

mlb jerseys

coach wallets

yeezy 350 v2

polo ralph lauren pas cher

ugg boots outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

red bottoms

michael kors outlet

jordan shoes

ray ban sunglasses

coach factory outlet

uggs outlet

nike huarache shoes

kate spade sale

louis vuitton outlet

cheap snapbacks

nike factory outlet

louboutin outlet

coach outlet

ralph lauren t shirt

moncler jacket

cheap oakley sunglasses

versace glasses

canada goose outlet

longchamp outlet online

oakley sunglasses wholesale

michael kors bags

coach outlet

air jordan shoes

adidas trainers uk

moncler jacket

michael kors outlet

ferragamo shoes

kate spade outlet

cheap nba jerseys

discount nike

canada goose outlet

coach outlet online 70% off

ugg boots

cheap ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

converse shoes

ugg canada

cheap jordans

nike air max 95

michael kors outlet online

uggs outlet online

new balance shoes

cheap jordan shoes

ugg australia

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

ugg boots

rolex datejust 2

birkenstock sandals

retro jordans

nfl jerseys

coach outlet online

christian louboutin outlet

nike roshe run

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren outlet

paul pogba jersey

ugg slippers

ugg australia boots

polo ralph lauren outlet

cheap jordan shoes

longchamp handbags

longchamp outlet

kate spade outlet

nike shoes

oakley sunglasses

coach factory outlet

adidas trainers

adidas shoes

ugg boots outlet

mk taschen

polo ralph lauren

ugg sale

salvatore ferragamo belt

michael kors uk

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

tory burch outlet online

uggs canada

uggs clearance

prada outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren españa

oakley sunglasses

rolex daytona

ralph lauren

ugg boots outlet

burberry canada

swarovski crystal

adidas originals

tory burch outlet online

hermes birkin bag

christian louboutin pas cher

ugg sale

montblanc pens

fitflops sale clearance

pandora canada

true religion sale

replica watches

cheap jordan shoes

north face outlet

burberry sale

moncler outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

ray ban aviators

cheap nfl jerseys

ugg boots on sale

ugg slippers

baseball jerseys

louis vuitton handbags

cheap oakley sunglasses

fitflop outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

ugg boots on sale

occhiali da sole ray ban

pandora charms

yeezy boost 350

ray ban sunglasses

burberry outlet online

coach outlet

uggs uk

ralph lauren outlet

nike store

birkenstock outlet

chenyingying20170921
문서 첨부 제한 : 0Byte/ 2.00MB
파일 크기 제한 : 2.00MB (허용 확장자 : *.*)
List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
공지 - 윌리엄 아이작스 <대화의 재발견>을 통한 인문학 독서모임 - 2017년 9월부터 평화세상 2017-08-10 203
공지 ‘회복과 돌봄의 서클’ 진행자양성 연구모임 안내 [1] 평화세상 2017-01-31 1362
공지 평화로 가는 독서모임2016.3.15-5.31 총10회 매주 화 오전10시-오후1시 file [1] 평화세상 2016-02-21 1275
공지 가르칠 수 있는 용기 10주 마지막 스케치-7장 더 이상 분열되지 않기 file [2] 평화세상 2015-12-03 1673
공지 서클대화모임 진행자 양성 워크숍 [1] 평화세상 2015-11-27 1477
공지 전체와 조각내기-데이비드 봄 [1] 평화세상 2015-05-10 1903
공지 마음자리 인문학 독서모임의 진행성찰-영혼의 자기 돌봄에 대해 [1] 평화세상 2014-12-20 1993
공지 문제와 역설-David Bohm [1] 평화세상 2014-12-20 1880
공지 사고방식의 근본적인 변화 [2] 평화세상 2014-06-02 2227
공지 신뢰의 공동체에 대한 묵상 [1] 평화세상 2014-05-25 3723
공지 분리된 삶으로부터 뫼비우스 띠 위의 삶으로-파커 파머 글 묵상 [1] 평화세상 2014-04-03 2268
11 > 삶은 이야기와 질문으로 유지된다 < 평화세상 2017-09-10 18
10 대화에 대한 성찰 1: 주변이 아닌 중심과 이야기하기 평화세상 2017-09-07 41
9 성령강림후 11주: 의식의 치유 [1] 평화세상 2017-08-20 153
8 삶의 내면작업을 통한 영혼의 감각 키우기 워크숍 [1] 평화세상 2017-08-13 168
7 돌봄과 회복의 서클 참여자 평가서 [1] 평화세상 2016-11-25 1062
6 교사를 위한 마음자리인문학 서클대화모임: “영혼의 여정으로서 가르침과 배움의 커뮤니티를 향하여” [1] 평화세상 2016-05-03 2427
» 파커 파머 리딩- 가르침을 학생들에게 의존하기 [2] 평화세상 2015-11-27 1697
4 파커 파머 리딩-부분을 통해 전체를 가르치기 [1] 평화세상 2015-11-17 1468
3 두려워하지 말라 -회복적생활교육 교사들 인문학독서모임 리딩 [1] 평화세상 2015-11-04 1595
2 “생명과 인간의 의미” 주제에 따른 서클 진행형 인문학 독서모임 소개 file [2] 평화세상 2015-05-12 1849
박성용박사 | ecopeace21@hanmail.net
XE Login